Skip to content

See the attendance impact we’re having in California! Read Now

Topbar Close icon
Site Logo
  • Products
    • Product Overview
    • Attend: Attendance Interventions
    • Connect: Family Engagement
    • Boost: Teacher Observation and Growth
    • Forms & Flows: Digital Forms and Payments
    • Sites: Accessible Websites
  • Who It’s For
    • Superintendents
    • District Leaders
    • School Leaders
    • Educators & Staff
    • Families
  • Resources
    • Resource Library
    • News & Press
    • Blog
    • Case Studies
    • Checklists & Infographics
    • eBooks
    • Guides & Playbooks
    • Reports
    • Webinars
  • About
    • About SchoolStatus
    • Careers
    • Contact
Request a Demo Log In
Request a Demo Log In
Educator Growth
Sep 04, 2014

Responding to Politico’s “Rating Teachers Not As Easy As 1, 2, 3”

SchoolStatus logo.
By SchoolStatus • 3 min
Share

Politico’s recent piece “Rating Teachers Not As Easy As 1, 2, 3” does a solid job of reporting on the landscape of teacher evaluation right now. In sum, despite all the rancor—or because of it—very little is happening:

Teachers union pressure, error-riddled evaluations and a wave of more difficult tests for students have won many teachers a reprieve from the newfangled evaluations during the school year now getting underway.

Specifically, Arne Duncan allowed states another year to tinker with standardized tests so value-added measures are fair and reliable. But other changes have already been implemented:

Six years into the Obama administration, most states have made big changes. Evaluations are more frequent and far more complex. Principals must often conduct several highly detailed classroom observations of each teacher each year. Some districts also include factors such as a teacher’s absentee rate, feedback from parents and students and peer review by colleagues. Objective measures of student learning—often, test scores—frequently account for 25 percent to 50 percent of the teacher’s evaluation.

Certainly, some of these changes constitute progress. To wit, previously “evaluations were often infrequent and superficial. The principal might walk into a classroom, check a few things off a checklist and make sure the classroom was under control.”

In fact, our friends at Bellwether recently published a report explaining that while states are all over the map on value added measures, some progress has been made, albeit inconsistently, on other aspects of teacher evaluation. Unfortunately, Bellwether argues, much of this progress has stalled.

Upon finishing the Politico piece, a reader would be excused for thinking that the situation is much worse—that no progress has been made at all, that this is an irreparably damaged system. But let’s not miss the forest for the trees.

We at TeachBoost happen to know for a fact that very positive developments are happening nationwide. We work with schools and districts across the country in which instructional leaders are fostering innovation among their faculty, master educators are mentoring novice teachers, and teacher evaluation is genuinely believed to be an opportunity for growth, as opposed to a punitive compliance measure.

We don’t take a position on the particular issues discussed in the Politico piece, though we know them to be important. Our platform supports districts in implementing whatever evaluation system they have. Still, we do hold fast to one idea: high-quality feedback, collaboration among educators, and growth-focused dialogue are essential to improved teaching and learning.

We hope legislators, lobbyists, and voters keep our philosophy in mind as well. However the legislation shakes out, we need systems that:

  • promote growth rather than stifle it;
  • allow districts to develop master teachers and build collaborative cultures;
  • enable districts to go beyond mere compliance, pursuing better teaching and learning instead.

It’s possible. We’ve seen it.

SchoolStatus logo.
SchoolStatus
SchoolStatus is transforming K-12 education with an integrated suite of solutions that provide educators and administrators with real-time student insights and district attendance trends, enabling complete visibility across all levels of the education ecosystem. Through data-driven, multi-channel communications including calling, texting, video, and print materials, SchoolStatus empowers educators to implement proactive interventions that enhance student outcomes and family engagement. With millions of successful school-home interactions, SchoolStatus leads the way in bridging the gap between schools and families across the U.S. SchoolStatus partners with thousands of districts and serves over 22 million students across all 50 states.

Stay Connected

News, articles, and tips for meeting your district’s goals—delivered to your inbox.

More Resources

5 Excel Functions Every Educator Needs to Know
Educator Growth
Sep 18, 2023

5 Excel Functions Every Educator Needs to Know

read more
Messaging and Communication are Not the Same Thing
Communication
Sep 24, 2020

Messaging and Communication are Not the Same Thing

read more
Happy woman working on her laptop.
Communication
Sep 1, 2021

Why PowerSchool Districts Choose SchoolStatus for Data Analysis

read more
Buttons on an arcade game.
Communication
May 24, 2016

3 Easy Ways to Gamify Your Professional Development

read more
Collaboration between SchoolStatus and Operoo.
Communication
Oct 26, 2021

SchoolStatus Acquires Operoo; Accelerates Vision to Build World’s Leading Unified K-12 Analytics, Communications, and Workflow Platform

read more
Happy woman in a black blazer working on her laptop.
Communication
Nov 15, 2021

How to Use Family Communication Data for Student Success

read more

Logo

Want Updates?

Stay connected with news, articles, and tips delivered to your inbox.

Stay in the Loop

Solutions

  • How it Works
  • Attendance Interventions
  • Family Engagement
  • Teacher Observation & Coaching
  • Administrative Efficiency
  • Data Analytics

Who It’s For

  • Superintendents
  • District Leaders
  • School Leaders
  • Educators & Staff
  • Families

Products

  • Product Overview
  • SchoolStatus Connect
  • SchoolStatus Attend
  • SchoolStatus Boost
  • SchoolStatus Forms & Flows
  • SchoolStatus Sites

Company

  • About SchoolStatus
  • Careers
  • Contact

Resources

  • Resource Library
  • News & Press
  • Blog
  • Case Studies
  • eBooks & Whitepapers
  • Webinars
  • Help Center
  • Customer Support
  • Website Terms of Use
  • SchoolStatus Privacy Policy
  • Accessibility
  • Sitemap
© 2025 SchoolStatus. All rights reserved